No quick fix for priest shortage in Amazon region pope says

A deacon prays in a chapel in Wijint, a village in the Peruvian Amazon, in August 2019. Photo: CNS/Reuters

VATICAN (CNS): In his apostolic exhortation, Querida Amazonia (Beloved Amazonia), which was released by the Vatican on February 12, Pope Francis acknowledged the serious shortage of priests in remote areas of the Amazon, but he insisted not all avenues have been exhausted to address the issue.

The pope said that confronting the priest shortage simply by “facilitating a greater presence of ordained ministers who can celebrate the Eucharist” would be “a very narrow aim.”

In October 2019, the members of the Synod of Bishops for the Amazon asked Pope Francis to open the way for the priestly ordination of married permanent deacons so that Catholics in the region could go to Mass and receive the sacraments regularly.

In response, Pope Francis wrote in his new document that the priest shortage must be seen as an opportunity for the Catholic Church to “awaken new life in communities.”

“We need to promote an encounter with God’s word and growth in holiness through various kinds of lay service that call for a process of education—biblical, doctrinal, spiritual and practical—and a variety of programmes of ongoing formation,” he said.

In an interview with Vatican News on February 12, Michael Cardinal Czerny, who served as secretary of the synod in October, said Pope Francis believes that “the question is not one of numbers and that a greater presence of priests is not the only requirement.”

The cardinal said, “What is needed is a presence of laypeople at the local level who are animated by a missionary spirit and capable of representing the authentic face of the Amazonian Church. This, he seems to indicate, is the only way that vocations will return.” 

Cardinal Czerny told journalists that while there is no mention in the pope’s document of ordaining married men to the priesthood or to women deacons, the pope “has not resolved them in any way beyond what he has said in the exhortation” (See page 6, Don’t clericalise women…).

READ  Vatican livestream

The synod is a journey “with long roads ahead as well as roads already travelled,” the cardinal said, adding, “If there are questions that you feel are open or that the Church feels are open, thanks to the exhortation they will continue to be debated, discussed, discerned, prayed over and when mature presented to the appropriate authority for decision.”

The cardinal said, “What is needed is a presence of laypeople at the local level who are animated by a missionary spirit and capable of representing the authentic face of the Amazonian Church. This, he seems to indicate, is the only way that vocations will return.” 

Pope Francis urged bishops, especially in Latin America, to encourage those who wish to be missionaries “to opt for the Amazon region.”

Much like in past exhortations, the pope drove the point home in the footnotes.

“It is noteworthy that, in some countries of the Amazon Basin, more missionaries go to Europe or the United States than remain to assist their own vicariates in the Amazon region,” he said.

While the shortage of vocations is an issue felt throughout the Church, even the severe shortages in places like the United States (US) pale in comparison to their Amazonian counterparts.

The Diocese of Fort Worth, Texas, for example, has an estimated 900,000 Catholics and a total of 103 priests, which is an average of one priest for every 8,737 people. It has one of the lowest ratios in the United States.

In comparison, the Diocese of Caxias do Maranhao, Brazil, has only 25 priests for a population of 825,000 Catholics, an average of one priest for every 33,000 people, while remote villages, such as the Kichwa indigenous community in the Ecuadorian Amazonian region, are difficult areas for priests to visit since they are accessible only by small plane or canoe.

READ  Pope Francis special message before Holy Week

In Querida Amazonia, the pope said that priests are essential for the full life of Catholic communities since they are the only ones who can consecrate the Eucharist and grant absolution in the sacrament of reconciliation.

“If we are truly convinced that this is the case, then every effort should be made to ensure that the Amazonian peoples do not lack this food of new life and the sacrament of forgiveness,” the pope said.

Nonetheless, Pope Francis also called for a renewal “of both initial and ongoing priestly formation” before considering other suggestions.

While priests are necessary, religious women, lay people and permanent deacons—”of whom there should be many more in the Amazon region”—could perform other functions necessary for Catholic life “with the aid of suitable accompaniment,” he pointed out.

Related articles
Don’t try to clericalise women in Amazon Church pope says

VATICAN (CNS): Pope Francis released Querida Amazonia, his postsynodal apostolic exhortation on the Amazon region, on the 15th anniversary of Read more

Ecological sin: Idea of updating catechism sparks debate

VATICAN (CNS): Pope Francis’ announcement that the Catechism of the Catholic Church would be updated to include a definition of Read more

Caring for common home requires deep ecological conversion synod says

VATICAN (CNS): The “unprecedented” environmental and social crisis in the Amazon calls for “a deep personal, social and structural conversion” Read more

Make disciples for Christ not yourself pope says

VATICAN (CNS): “What instructions does the Lord give us for going forth to others? Only one, and it’s very simple: Read more